Skip to main content
All articles

Buying a home

Rent or buy: what a fair comparison needs to include

What to count when you compare renting with buying: upfront costs, ongoing costs, the assumptions behind any tool, and what a cash comparison leaves out.

Written by Afiyah Capital, credit representative. Last reviewed 17 October 2026.

A hand working a calculator beside a small model house and some papers
In this article
  1. What buying costs
  2. What renting costs
  3. Assumptions drive the answer
  4. Why the same numbers can give different answers
  5. How the finance side works in Islamic home finance
  6. What a cash comparison leaves out
  7. Questions a comparison can help you ask

Rent or buy is a cash question and a life question. A comparison can only cover the cash side. This article lists what that side includes.

Stamp duty
a one-off tax that a state or territory charges when property changes hands
LMI
lenders mortgage insurance, a one-off cost that protects the lender, not you
Break-even point
the year in which the total cost of buying falls to the total cost of renting
Opportunity cost
what the same money could have done if it had not gone into a deposit

What buying costs

Moneysmart lists costs at two stages: when you buy, and while you own the home.

Upfront costs

  • The deposit. Moneysmart suggests a goal of 20% of the price, plus enough to cover buying costs.
  • Stamp duty, a one-off state or territory tax. The amount depends on where the property is, what it is worth and your circumstances. First home buyers may be eligible for an exemption, rebate or concession.
  • Legal or conveyancing fees.
  • Building and pest inspections.
  • Lenders mortgage insurance (LMI), if the deposit is small. Moneysmart says a 20% deposit can help you avoid it.

Ongoing costs

  • Repayments on the finance.
  • Council rates, utilities and maintenance.
  • Home and contents insurance.

What renting costs

  • Rent, and any change to it at each review.
  • A rental bond and the costs of moving.
  • Contents insurance.

Rent pays for somewhere to live and builds no ownership share. Part of each repayment on a purchase can build one. Property values can also fall.

Assumptions drive the answer

A comparison over several years needs assumptions. Three matter most.

  1. How much rent changes each year.
  2. How the property value changes.
  3. How the cost of the finance changes.

No one can predict these. A fair comparison shows more than one case. One of them should be a case where values stay flat or fall.

Moneysmart suggests testing your repayments against a rise in rates. In Islamic home finance the cost is a rental or profit rate, which can also change over time.

Why the same numbers can give different answers

Two people with the same price and rent can reach different results. Deposit size, how long they stay and how the property value moves all change the answer.

Change one input at a time. Note which assumption moves the result most.

How the finance side works in Islamic home finance

In Islamic home finance, the payments are made up of rent, profit or a share purchase, depending on the structure. Ask how each part is set and when it is reviewed.

What a cash comparison leaves out

  • Selling costs when you eventually sell.
  • Tax.
  • Changes in rates over the term.
  • The opportunity cost of the deposit and the upfront costs.
  • Your own circumstances, such as job security and how long you plan to stay.
  • Non-cash factors, such as stability, flexibility and control over the home.

Questions a comparison can help you ask

  • How long do I expect to stay? A longer stay spreads the upfront costs over more years.
  • What does the result look like if values stay flat?
  • How much cash is left after the upfront costs?
  • Could I still meet the repayments if rates rose?
  • Is there a break-even point, and how much does it move if an assumption changes?
  • Which costs have I left out because they are hard to estimate?

Note

Our rent vs buy planner on the Tools and guides page follows this list. It is an illustration using the figures you enter and the assumptions shown. It isn't a quote, an offer, a credit assessment or an approval. Outcomes can be worse than shown.

To talk through the finance side, start an enquiry.

Start my enquiry

Sources and dates

Every figure above comes from one of these, read on the date shown. If a source has moved on, the article is reviewed again.

  1. Moneysmart: Buying a house (last updated 14 October 2026) · read 17 October 2026
  2. Moneysmart: Save for a house deposit (last updated 6 August 2026) · read 17 October 2026
  3. Moneysmart: lenders mortgage insurance (LMI) (last updated 16 September 2019) · read 17 October 2026
  4. Moneysmart: Choosing a home loan (last updated 16 September 2026) · read 17 October 2026

Ready to talk about your situation?

Three short steps. Or pick a time to talk with your Afiyah team.